Wokingham council ‘cleared’ in investigation despite resident concerns

by | Sep 3, 2019 | News | 0 comments

garden centres

An investigation into the behaviour of councillors involved in a legal battle between Wokingham Borough Council and Hare Hatch Sheeplands found suggestions of unprofessional conduct were “unfounded”.

The council commissioned non-practising solicitor Richard Lingard to look into how councillors and officers conducted themselves in the run-up to court action. It saw Sheeplands owner Rob Scott prosecuted over unauthorised development at the site.
 
Judge Angela Morris said Wokingham Borough Council had “sought to gain advantage” of the situation by taking a “flawed” decision to prosecute Mr Scott. This was after he withdrew his appeal to a council enforcement notice.
 
Mr Lingard’s verdict suggested judges drew “the wrong inference” after courts determined the authority was wrong.
 
A local resident said: “His attempt to be a new court of law, and his findings that the court of appeal and the crown court were wrong in coming to their conclusions, is appalling.
 
“The court of appeal has now ruled – that is the position and that is the fact!
 
“This re-run is wholly unacceptable.”
 
The report came to some conclusions after Mr Lingard interviewed councillors involved. He also interviewed Mr Scott.
 
Mr Lingard has already been involved in the Hare Hatch saga. HJe was asked to provide support in relation to the disclosure of documents relevant to the Crown Court case.
 
According to Mr Lingard, councillors and officers did not persuade Mr Scott to withdraw an appeal.
 
Some councillors did come in for criticism. Officers interviewed described their participation as making the job “more difficult” and as a “hindrance”. This resulted in Mr Lingard ruling elected members shouldn’t have got involved in discussions with Mr Scott.

Wokingham Council’s Leader “sad”

 
Councillor John Halsall, leader of the council said: “I’m sad that we weren’t able to find an accommodation for Hare Hatch.
 
“I’m relieved Richard Lingard didn’t find any evidence of maladministration within Wokingham Borough Council.
 
“Mr Lingard is a very professional person who does this sort of work and he looked at what the courts said.
 
“The ward councillor’s job is to represent their constituents. One of my constituents is Hare Hatch.
 
“I would without hesitation try to help in any way I can the owners of Hare Hatch.”
 
Fellow supporter Frank Moore added: “We called for an investigation.
 
“We’ve seen Mr Lingard’s report now and there are huge gaps in the report where paragraphs are missing.
 
“I don’t think it’s a full review – I don’t think it’s the end of the case and I don’t think they’ve done a very good job.”
 
Liberal Democrats councillor Clive Jones said: “I’m very surprised. He appears to have rubbished the courts decisions. I would like to know why eleven paragraphs have been redacted – I don’t see why it has been necessary to do so.
 
“It isn’t an open investigation with that sort of thing happening.”

more latest news ➡

Klondyke Group announces Outdoor Living showcase

Klondyke Group’s Outdoor Living Showcase

A sprinkling of Sherbert through the Cottage garden; the simplicity and calmness of Urban Nature through to the mood and mystery of Moroccan Delights; these were amongst the main themes revealed at the Klondyke Group's Outdoor Living Showcase Event hosted this week...

GCA BoT results show garden projects on the up

January’s GCA BoT results reveal rise in garden projects

Hard landscaping topped the sales table in the Garden Centre Association’s (GCA) Barometer of Trade (BoT) report for January 2024 with hardy plants, seeds and bulbs also doing well. Figures recorded by GCA member garden centres last month show a good start to the...

Rising stars nominations deadline 1 March

March 1 deadline for Rising Stars nominations

The GCA is urging members to get their 2024 Rising Stars nominations in by March 1 to help showcase and develop the industry’s most talented individuals this year. The Westland Horticulture sponsored programme offers those who participate the chance to be mentored...

Handy drops new catalogue for 2024 season

Handy unveils the latest gardening and DIY products

British garden manufacturer Handy has announced the arrival of its new catalogue and Monthly Dealer Promotions Calendar, both designed to provide retailers with valuable increased margins on a wide range of gardening and DIY products and ensure they have everything...

HTA shows caution for garden retailers

Garden Centres cautious despite good start to year

The Horticultural Trades Association (HTA) releases its February monthly market update, which shows that despite the UK economy's recently announced recession, garden retail continues to show some green shoots to kick off the year. The resilience is a continuity of...

Read GCR's latest edition!
Read GCR's latest Made in Britain Supplement!

Subscribe ToThe Wednesday Word

Subscribe To
The Wednesday Word

 

Get all the latest news, events & more straight to your inbox every Wednesday.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This